Want to talk to an expert employment law solicitor?

You'll receive a callback from a specialist within an hour

In the case of Martin v Devonshire Solicitors UKEAT/0086/10/DA the Employment Appeal Tribunal approached the question of whether a dismissal had been motivated by a complaint of discrimination by asking the question: “what is the reason for the act complained of?”. The EAT concluded in this case that the reason for the claimant’s dismissal had been the manner of her complaints, rather than the nature of the complaint, and that the Tribunal had been correct to find against the claimant.

The facts in Martin v Devonshire Solicitors

Mrs Martin, a legal secretary at a firm of solicitors who had a job share, made allegations that two of the partners at the firm had made derogatory comments about her relating to a previous Employment Tribunal case that she had brought against another law firm. She also made allegations that she was being denied job opportunities at the firm.

Mrs Martin’s grievances were investigated and it was found that the two partners had not made the derogatory remarks about her; disciplinary proceedings were therefore commenced against Mrs Martin on allegations that she had falsified the contents of her grievance against the partners. However, the disciplinary process against Mrs Martin was subsequently discontinued as Devonshires obtained a medical report from an occupational health consultant which stated that Mrs Martin had a history of ill health. This report was also supported by the report of a consultant psychiatrist, who concluded that Mrs Martin had experienced a long history of mental illness, that her allegations against the partners might have been caused by her mental illness, and that it was likely that her mental illness would recur in the future.

Although the disciplinary proceedings against Mrs Martin were discontinued on the strength of the medical reports, she was subsequently dismissed in July 2008 from her employment on allegations that the bond of trust and confidence between her and her employer had broken down as a result of the complaints that she had made against the partners.

After being dismissed from her employment Mrs Martin brought Employment Tribunal claims for victimisation and unfair dismissal. These claims were dismissed by the London Central Employment Tribunal as the Tribunal found her dismissal fair and, further, that the reason for her dismissal was her continuing mental ill health and risk of further disruptive behaviour by Mrs Martin (and not her complaint per se). Mrs Martin appealed the Tribunal’s decision to the Employment Appeal Tribunal.

The Employment Appeal Tribunal, chaired by Underhill J (as he was then), upheld the Employment Tribunal’s decision as it found that the reason for Mrs Martin’s dismissal was not wholly or in substantial part her complaint that she had been victimised; the EAT found instead that the Tribunal had been entitled to find that the reason for her dismissal was her conduct at work and the manner in which she had complained to the firm, and that the reason for her dismissal could be “properly treated as separable”. Mrs Martin’s appeal was therefore dismissed.

What does this case mean for me?

If you are an employee with a victimisation claim, then you must carefully analyse your claim to determine whether there is a reason for your dismissal (or detriment, as relevant) which is “properly separable” from the complaint itself – if so, then the other side may have a strong defence to your claim.

If you are an employer, then you must investigate any grievances reasonably, thoroughly, and impartially (and produce outcomes which are equally as reasonable, thorough, and impartial). If an Employment Tribunal claim is made against you then you should carefully analyse the claim to see whether there is a “reason for” defence available to you.

What effect has this case had?

This case has afforded (along with a number of other similar cases relating to discrimination and whistleblowing) employers the opportunity to argue that an employee was not subjected to a detriment or dismissed because of a complaint but, alternatively, because of the manner in which that complaint was made (or another relevant reason not relevant to the complaint).

The transcript of Martin v Devonshire Solicitors UKEAT/0086/10/DA can be found here.

About Chris Hadrill

Chris is a specialist employment lawyer at Redmans. He specialises in contentious and non-contentious employment matters, including breach of contract claims, compromise agreements and Employment Tribunal cases. He writes on employment law matters on a variety of websites, including Direct 2 Lawyers, Lawontheweb.co.uk, LegalVoice, the Justice Gap and his own blog. Contact Chris by emailing him at chadrill@redmans.co.uk

Want to talk to an expert employment law solicitor?

You'll receive a callback from a specialist within an hour

Our awards

Request a callback

    Your first name (required)

    Your last name (required)

    Your email (required)

    Your telephone number (required)

    Brief details of your enquiry

    Testimonials

    4.80 Average

    371 Reviews

    Jonathan L

    The service I received was friendly and professional. I appreciated the timely communications and Mel was always available for any questions I had. I'd definitely recommend Redmans and will use them in a heartbeat should the situation arise again.

    Posted 6 days ago

    Glyn B

    Provided a great service, covered all my requirements

    Posted 1 week ago

    Fidel A

    Redmans Solicitors recently helped me navigate a recent employment termination settlement agreement. Chris Hadrill is very professional and you will be in good hands with him. I score Redmans 4 out of 5 because things had to move fast and felt the team member assigned to my case wasn't very responsive at times. Having said that, I was very happy with the outcome and have no hesitation in recommending their services.

    Posted 1 week ago

    Nigel A

    Chris Hadrill is hugely impressive - the right blend of assured calm and savvy professionalism. I've already recommended him to friends and family.

    Posted 1 week ago

    Matt O

    I was hugely impressed with the ease of being able to work with Redmans Solicitors and their professional approach. Mel was really clear around the process, and costings required and I felt comfortable throughout. I would certainly recommend.

    Posted 1 week ago

    Bryan G

    Great response, and also happy to assist

    Posted 1 week ago

    David L

    I was made a settlement offer by my employer to terminate my emplyment early. Redmans helped me understand the offer, and ensured that it was fair for someone in my position. They made a very stressful situation much easier. Excellent service.

    Posted 1 week ago

    Anonymous

    I can highly recommend Redmans. The service was professional and prompt and I would not hesitate to use them again. Thanks

    Posted 2 weeks ago

    Anonymous

    Overall I am satisfied with the performance from Redmans. The reason I have given 4 stars is that I had quite a lot difficulty in contacting the representative which was initially nominated for me. However, when I contacted Chris instead, he was excellent over the phone and secured a great outcome in short order. I would recommend Redmans Solicitors.

    Posted 2 weeks ago

    Anonymous

    Chris and Redmans were a great help. Effective and efficient, quick response from my first enquiry and then straightforward and attentive throughout with ultimately a positive outcome. I will use them again and recommend them.

    Posted 3 weeks ago

    Marie P

    Great service, quick responses, good advice and all in a no nonsense, no jargon manner. Would definitely recommend.

    Posted 3 weeks ago

    Anonymous

    Rana was amazingly thorough and professional!

    Posted 3 weeks ago

    Anonymous

    I am extremely happy with the legal advice I was provided with. My case was resolved to the best of my expectations. Thank you very much for your professional help.

    Posted 3 weeks ago

    Shahzad R

    Chris and his team were excellent. They provided sound advice and consultation that resulted in more cash than was offered. Would definitely recommend.

    Posted 3 weeks ago

    Sanjay B

    I would like to take this opportunity to thank Mel Chin, for all her support during my settlement process. Where she provided a professional service and was understanding. I would confidently recommend Redmans Solicitors to my friends and family. Thank you and wishing you all a Merry Christmas.

    Posted 1 month ago

    Paul O

    Excellent response time and communication during my dealings with Redmans

    Posted 1 month ago

    Gil T

    I don’t normally write reviews, but thought it was time on this occasion. Just wanted to say that I highly recommend Redmans - especially Rana Tandon, who helped me navigate around my employment contract. Rana was meticulous and thorough and all over my needs. Would I use Redmans again ? ..absolutely

    Posted 1 month ago

    Stephanie D

    Very thorough and professional service. I was very nervous about my employment case, as I had never dealt with anything like it before. However, the solicitors who handled my case made sure I understood everything. I was never kept in the dark and Redmans kept me constantly informed about what was going on with my case. I would definitely recommend Redmans Solicitors

    Posted 1 month ago

    Richard S

    Chris and Sacha were great throughout the entire process. Chris was very helpful once the initial discussions with my company began and before we agreed there was a case. Sacha was very responsive, patient and helpful throughout ensuring I felt I had the right information to make the best decision on next steps. A close friend and wife have both used Redmans in the past few years for unfair dismissals and the service continues to be first-class and I would strongly recommend them again. They definitely help reduce the anxiety that comes with uncertainty around new processes and situations. Thank you!

    Posted 1 month ago

    Jianya

    Very nice and patient went through the whole document with me.

    Posted 1 month ago

    Susan L

    Very helpful and led me through the redundancy process.

    Posted 1 month ago