Want to talk to an expert employment law solicitor?

You'll receive a callback from a specialist within an hour

redmans-blog-analysisIn the case of Hayward v Zurich Insurance Co Plc [2016] UKSC 48 the Supreme Court held that a settlement agreement that had been entered into between two parties could be set aside due to evidence of fraudulent conduct.

In 1998 Mr Hayward was injured in an accident at work and brought a claim for negligence against his employers. The case was dealt with on the employer’s behalf by its insurers, Zurich Insurance Company plc (“Zurich”). Liability in the case was agreed and the parties reached a settlement agreement in October 2003, shortly before the quantum hearing was due to be held. This settlement agreement stipulated that the employer (in practice Zurich) would pay £134,973.11 in full and final settlement of Mr Hayward’s claims.

In 2005 Mr Hayward’s neighbours (who had moved into their property in 2002) contacted Mr Hayward’s employers to inform them that they did not believe that Mr Hayward was being honest about the state of his injuries, and further informed them that they believed that Mr Hayward had recovered in full from his injuries at least a year before settlement was agreed. They gave witness statements to Zurich to that effect.

In 2009 Zurich commenced proceedings against Mr Hayward, claiming damages for deceit. Zurich argued that Mr Hayward’s witness statements, his statement of case in the Particulars of Claim, and his Schedules of Loss as to the extent of his injury contained fraudulent misrepresentations. The damages that were claimed by Zurich amounted to the difference between what the case had been settled for and what the case would have been worth if Mr Hayward had been telling the truth. The claim was later amended to state that Zurich was looking to set the compromise agreement aside rather than for an order for damages.

The case came to the Cambridge County Court in November 2012, with the Court finding that Mr Hayward had deliberately and dishonestly exaggerated the effects of his injuries during the court process. The judge also found that the settlement agreement had been entered into by Zurich on the reliance of false representations given by Mr Hayward, and that the settlement agreement should therefore be set aside. The judge found that Mr Hayward would have fully recovered from his injuries by October 1999 and handed down a judgment awarding Mr Hayward damages to the sum of £14,720. An order was also given that Mr Hayward must repay Zurich the sum of £136,110.45.

Mr Hayward appealed against the decision of the Court, arguing that the settlement agreement should not have been set aside. The Court of Appeal ruled in Mr Hayward’s favour, finding that Zurich had been aware at the time that the settlement agreement was entered into that Mr Hayward may have been exaggerating the extent of his injuries. Zurich appelaed to the Supreme Court on the grounds that, regardless of whether Zurich had believed in Mr Hayward’s representations regarding the effects of his injuries, it had been induced to enter into the settlement agreement as a result of these fraudulent representations.

The Supreme Court ruled in Zurich’s favour, holding that it was not necessary for Zurich to show that it believed that the (mis)representations made by Mr Hayward were true but that it merely had to show that it had been induced to enter into the settlement agreement by the misrepresentations (i.e. that the misrepresentations were a material cause for Zurich to enter into the settlement) and that these misrepresentations had caused them loss.

Chris Hadrill, a specialist employment solicitor at Redmans, commented on the case: “This is an important judgment by the Supreme Court in both the contexts of personal injury and employment law – if defendants to litigation can obtain clear and cogent evidence that the other side had misrepresented their case then this could lead to a challenge to any settlement agreement reached between the parties.”

The transcript of Hayward v Zurich Insurance Co Plc [2016] UKSC 48 can be found here

About

Redmans Employment Team deal with employment matters for both employers and employees, including drafting employment contracts and policies, advising employers and employees on compromise agreements, handling day-to-day HR issues, advising on restructures, and handling Employment Tribunal cases for both employers and employees Call 020 3397 3603 to speak to one of the members of our employment team or email us on enquiries@redmans.co.uk. Redmans have offices in Richmond, Chiswick, Hammersmith, Fulham, Kingston, Wimbledon, Ealing, Kings Cross and Marylebone (meetings strictly by appointment only).

Tagged with →  

Want to talk to an expert employment law solicitor?

You'll receive a callback from a specialist within an hour

Share →

Our awards

Request a callback

Your name

Your email

Your telephone number

Contact us

Please feel free to discuss your own position and concerns. Contact your nearest office on:

T: 020 3397 3603
E: enquiries@redmans.co.uk
W: www.redmans.co.uk

Testimonials

4.78 Average

143 Reviews

Liz P

An excellent professional service was provided by Chris Hadrill and Mel Chin. Efficient and trustworthy - would highly recommend this company.

Posted 1 week ago

Anonymous

Redmans Solicitors were great. They were able to advice me quickly and efficiently! I would recommend them, as a good solicitors to use.

Posted 1 week ago

Anonymous

Extremely efficient. Mel made a difficult situation bearable and gave good clear guidance thoughout.

Posted 2 weeks ago

Anonymous

Thanks Chris and Sacha I was reassured throughout the process and a happy outcome

Posted 2 weeks ago

Edward F

Good and clear employment advice

Posted 2 weeks ago

Richard O

Chris at Redmans is my go-to legal expert when it comes to employee-related matters. His depth of knowledge, experience and considered approach to problems and their solutions is highly valuable. I cannot recommend Redmans highly enough.

Posted 4 weeks ago

Rory Y

They provide me with timely and clear advice!

Posted 1 month ago

Steven C

Redmans handled my settlement with my employer quickly, decisively and to a standard that I was very happy with. I would in similar circumstances contract them again

Posted 1 month ago

Deepthi K

Transparent. Clear communication. Prompt reply’s. Saves lot of time. Very satisfied.

Posted 1 month ago

Anonymous

Chris and Sacha did a fantastic job and negotiated a significant better settlement agreement

Posted 1 month ago

Dino D

I did get a very swift and god service from Redmans

Posted 1 month ago

Stephanie H

Clear, prompt, effective support from Chris which has been very much appreciated. Thank you again.

Posted 1 month ago

Anonymous

I would highly recommend Redmans Solicitors, the team were very friendly and my case was dealt with professionally and efficiently. Thank you!

Posted 2 months ago

Shane M

Very professional, welcome advice at a crucial time. Always available and reasonable cost.

Posted 2 months ago

Anonymous

My case was relatively straight-forward. But even so, working with Redmans was easy, quick, professional & clear. Many thanks

Posted 2 months ago

Anonymous

The team were very helpful and answered all my questions regarding my redundancy. Initially I had a call with one of the representatives who escalated my request to a suitable employment solicitor. We arranged a call to discuss the settlement and she helped answer all my questions. We then mainly contacted through email which helped resolve the settlement quickly and convently. Thanks for all the help.

Posted 2 months ago

Djaouida T

You have good communication.

Posted 2 months ago

Anonymous

Fast and professional. A highly recommended company for employment related issues.

Posted 2 months ago

Anonymous

Very professional service.

Posted 2 months ago

Brittany

I was very grateful for Redmans to treat my case with respect and discretion. At the time, I was very new to London and it was meaningful to have someone on my side and win the case for me. Without any doubt, I would definitely recommend Redmans Solicitors to anyone who is in need of it.

Posted 10 months ago

Jake L

Chris is very professional and calm. Very attentive and patient, been a positive experience having Chris represent me, and would recommend him.

Posted 11 months ago