Want to talk to an expert employment law solicitor?

You'll receive a callback from a specialist within an hour

In this post we’re going to look at the recent Employment Appeal Tribunal case of Plymouth City Council v White UKEAT/0333/13/LA, which covered applications for specific disclosure and when disclosure can be ordered by an Employment Judge.

Synopsis: the Employment Appeal Tribunal found that the Employment Judge had erred in applying a “relevance” test instead of whether a “necessary” test i.e. whether the documents where necessary for a fair trial.

The facts in Plymouth City Council v White UKEAT/0333/13/LA

The claimant, who was dismissed after the respondent discovered facts which suggested he had a “propensity for violence”, brought an unfair dismissal claim in the employment tribunal in 2012 (as well as a discrimination claim which was subsequently struck out). There was a five-hour case management discussion in May 2013 relating to the disclosure of documents for the employment tribunal and the Employment Judge ordered that a number of documents must be disclosed by the respondent because they were “relevant” to the claim brought by the claimant. The respondent subsequently appealed this ruling, claiming that the Employment Judge had applied the wrong test.

The law relating to applications for specific disclosure

The law relating to applications for specific disclosure in the Employment Tribunal is fairly clear. Under the (old rules) the Employment Tribunal may order disclosure against any person in Great Britain, as long as the documents are both relevant and necessary for fairly disposing of the proceedings.

The Employment Appeal Tribunal’s decision in Plymouth City Council v White UKEAT/0333/13/LA

The Employment Appeal Tribunal, chaired by HHJ McMullen, determined that the Employment Judge had applied the wrong test in ordering disclosure of documents, as he had applied the “relevance” test without considering whether the documents were necessary for a fair trial. The correct test, as helpfully laid out by HHJ McMullen in the judgment, is as follows:

  1. The Judge must first consider whether the document sought is relevant
  2. If it is relevant, the next question is whether it is necessary for the fair trial of the case for it to be ordered to be disclosed. Where there is an objection based upon confidentiality of the document in question, the Judge should examine the document itself to determine whether or not it should still be disclosed
  3. If the document is relevant and necessary and is to be disclosed, the Judge should consider whether there is a more nuanced way of disclosing the material so as to respect confidentiality and may decided to order disclosure of the document partially or wholly, normally through redaction of the document
  4. The Employment Judge, upon having read the documents and ordered disclosure, should not conduct the full hearing unless the parties agree to this.

About Chris Hadrill

Chris is a specialist employment lawyer at Redmans. He specialises in contentious and non-contentious employment matters, including breach of contract claims, compromise agreements and Employment Tribunal cases. He writes on employment law matters on a variety of websites, including Direct 2 Lawyers, Lawontheweb.co.uk, LegalVoice, the Justice Gap and his own blog. Contact Chris by emailing him at chadrill@redmans.co.uk

Want to talk to an expert employment law solicitor?

You'll receive a callback from a specialist within an hour

Share →

Our awards

Request a callback

Your name

Your email

Your telephone number

Contact us

Please feel free to discuss your own position and concerns. Contact your nearest office on:

T: 020 3397 3603
E: enquiries@redmans.co.uk
W: www.redmans.co.uk

Testimonials

4.76 Average

176 Reviews

Mohamed A

Super helpful and efficient, trustworthy service

Posted 3 days ago

Anonymous

efficient, responsive and effective

Posted 3 days ago

Andrew B

Very good service

Posted 3 days ago

Anonymous

Excellent service, compassionate and a good outcome

Posted 4 days ago

Anonymous

I had an employment issue which required legal advice. Chris was very supportive and knowledgeable, resulting in an optimum resolution in my favour. Would definitely recommend.

Posted 1 week ago

David M

Very professional and first-rate advice. I would use again. With thanks,

Posted 1 week ago

Anonymous

Got the job done swiftly without going too much in to detail.

Posted 1 week ago

Derek W

Redmans dealt with my case very efficiently and I was happy with the outcome.

Posted 1 week ago

Anonymous

Timely professional advice!

Posted 2 weeks ago

Anonymous

Very good service

Posted 2 weeks ago

Anonymous

I was in contact with Chris and then worked with Caroline on an employment matter. I was very pleased with the service and professionalism throughout, and came away with satisfied with the outcome. Would happily recommend.

Posted 2 weeks ago

Nikki

Received advice re employment law. Chris was very helpful and advised accordingly. Would happily recommend them and if ever I need help again, will not think twice before using them.

Posted 3 weeks ago

Samantha K

Absolutely brilliant thank you. Caroline Lewis is a legend

Posted 2 months ago

Anonymous

The legal advice was clear and helpful.

Posted 2 months ago

Davinder P

Good Service

Posted 2 months ago

Adrian V

I was using Redmans services for a Settlement Agreement. Very quick and professional service. The outcome was favourable and I was very pleased with the amendments and results. Pretty glad to recommend them for any type of legal advice.

Posted 2 months ago

Anonymous

Very responsive, efficient, clear and supportive. Thank you! Highly recommend.

Posted 2 months ago

Tiago S

Chris was always prompt to help me with legal matters that are beyond my comprehension and very helpful leasing with my former employer. I would recommend Redmans Solicitors to everyone who needs help.

Posted 2 months ago

Anonymous

Fast and professional advice tailored to what was needed. Thanks for your help Chris Hadrill and team.

Posted 2 months ago

Peter S

Really pleased with the outcome and the advice I had from Chris and Sacha.

Posted 2 months ago

Harika A

Redmans solicitor's helped me with my settlement agreement, Chris has been very helpful throughout the process.He was very prompt in his responses and made my settlement look simple.Special thanks to Caroline for her efficient communication, thorough explaination of contract terminology and negotiations.I highly reccommend Redmans solicitors for anyone seeking employment related legal help.

Posted 2 months ago