Want to talk to an expert employment law solicitor?

You'll receive a callback from a specialist within an hour

In the case of Nosworthy v Instinctif Partners Limited EAT/0100/18/RN, the Employment Appeal Tribunal (the ‘EAT”) held that the Employment Tribunal (the ‘ET’) had been correct in dismissing the claims made by an employee who had lost the right to receive cash payment, loan notes and new shares in her employer when she voluntarily resigned from her employer.

The Facts in Nosworthy v Instinctif Partners Limited

Miss Nosworthy (the ‘Claimant’) was given a 2% shareholding in her employer, Communications Operations Limited, which was then sold with the rest of the company’s shares when it was acquired by Instinctif Partners (the ‘Respondent’). As a result, the Claimant was entitled to deferred payment for part of her shares under a three year ‘earn-out’ scheme in the Share Purchase Agreement which provided for her to receive cash payments, loan notes and new shares in the Respondent.

These arrangements served as a mechanism by the Respondent to incentivise retention of key employees. Bad leaver provisions meant the Claimant received £143 for her shares and forfeited loan notes when she voluntarily resigned in 2016 as she lost their entitlement to earn-out payments and had to sell her loan notes and new shares back to the Respondent at their acquisition cost.

The decision of the Employment Tribunal

The Claimant brought a claim in the Employment Tribunal and challenged the bad leaver provisions on three grounds:

  1. that they were “unconscionable” and therefore unenforceable
  2. that they amounted to an unlawful penalty clause
  3. that they amounted to an unlawful deduction from her wage

All arguments raised by the Claimant were rejected by the Employment Tribunal and she went on to appeal the decision in the Employment Appeal Tribunal.

The decision of the Employment Appeal Tribunal

Unconscionable Bargain

Here the EAT reminded itself that this required that “one party has to have been disadvantaged in some relevant way as regards the other party, that other party must have exploited that disadvantage in some morally culpable manner, and the resulting transaction must be overreaching and oppressive”. It held that there was no evidence of serious disadvantage whether through poverty, or ignorance or lack of advice (the Claimant had confirmed she had received legal advice on the agreement at the time of entering into them).  The first ground of appeal therefore failed.

Unlawful Penalty Clause

The EAT was also unconvinced by the argument that such provisions were an unlawful penalty clause. A penalty clause relates to damages for breach of contract which are purely a deterrent against a breach rather than a genuine pre-estimate of loss. Penalty clauses are generally unenforceable.  Thus, a penalty has to operate on a breach of contract.  The investment agreement, to which the Claimant was a party, contained a covenant that she would not become a bad leaver (as defined in the Articles of Association). Whilst it was acknowledged that the Claimant had breached the investment agreement, the Respondent was not relying on this breach to enforce the bad leaver provisions; it was simply applying the standalone rules set out in its Articles of Association. Therefore, the issue of penalties was not relevant in this case.

Unlawful Deduction from Wages

Finally, the EAT held that this could not amount to an unlawful deduction from wages under section 27(2)(e) of the Employment Rights Act 1996.  Whilst the claim in respect of earn-out shares and loan notes could be said to be payable in connection with employment, they were deferred consideration for the sale of her shares and therefore provided to the Claimant as a vendor of shares, not in her capacity as a worker.

Our solicitors’ views on the case of Nosworthy v Instinctif Partners Limited UKEAT/0100/18/RN

Sacha Barrett, a Senior Associate in the employment department at Redmans, made the following comments on the case: “This case highlights the importance of employees taking legal advice prior to entering into a share scheme as widely drafted bad leaver provisions can be enforceable.’

The decision of the Employment Appeal Tribunal in UKEAT/0100/18/RN can be found here.

About

Redmans Employment Team deal with employment matters for both employers and employees, including drafting employment contracts and policies, advising employers and employees on compromise agreements, handling day-to-day HR issues, advising on restructures, and handling Employment Tribunal cases for both employers and employees Call 020 3397 3603 to speak to one of the members of our employment team or email us on enquiries@redmans.co.uk. Redmans have offices in Richmond, Chiswick, Hammersmith, Fulham, Kingston, Wimbledon, Ealing, Kings Cross and Marylebone (meetings strictly by appointment only).

Want to talk to an expert employment law solicitor?

You'll receive a callback from a specialist within an hour

Share →

Our awards

Request a callback

    Your first name (required)

    Your last name (required)

    Your email (required)

    Your telephone number (required)

    Brief details of your enquiry

    Testimonials

    4.80 Average

    330 Reviews

    Arabella B

    I am so grateful to Caroline Lewis at Redmans Solicitor’s for helping me with my Unfair Dismissal Case. I was seriously impressed how easy Redmans made the whole case, and am very happy with my Settlement. I have recommended your firm to at least 5 people in the last 3 months.. Thank you Caroline and everyone at Redmans. You are Brilliant .

    Posted 1 day ago

    Anonymous

    Highly professional and efficient service.

    Posted 1 day ago

    Tanya T

    I had the pleasure of Chris and Sacha’s experience with a work matter. They made me feel at ease with the process and explained everything thoroughly. Would happily recommend Redmans especially Chris and use them if needed I’m the future. Thank you!

    Posted 1 day ago

    Anonymous

    I used the services of Redmans solicitors and was a quick outstanding service I engaged them in a settlement agreement after been made redundant extremely professional at all that was done and would definetly use them again

    Posted 1 day ago

    Adrian A

    Spot on support, enough to get the matter at hand sorted. No beating around the bush, no nonsense - got the job done and we all moved on.

    Posted 1 day ago

    Mark Q

    Five Stars I was most impressed by the attention, courtesy, speed and above all, professionalism in dealing with my Settlement Agreement. I would certainly have no problem in recommending this firm to anyone in need of their services.

    Posted 1 week ago

    Ade A

    I was surprisingly impressed by how Redmans Solicitors handle my case. From the moment I call them to the absolute end of my case, they always look after my best interest.

    Posted 1 week ago

    Malcolm P

    they were there when others were not

    Posted 2 weeks ago

    Anonymous

    Excellent service all the way through from start to finish. Really great support and guidance from the team, they secured the offer that I wanted. I can't recommend Redmans highly enough and will be sure to use their services again should the need arise.

    Posted 2 weeks ago

    Anonymous

    Efficient and quick service!

    Posted 1 month ago

    Karen B

    Quick response very helpful Issue raised dealt with very quickly

    Posted 1 month ago

    Carmen T

    Redmans give Great service and advice on reading contracts. They can explain all the solicitors jargon into words that you can understand. I received excellent service an I will use them again and again.

    Posted 1 month ago

    Anonymous

    Very grateful for Mel’s efforts in handling my case from start to finish which I would have found very stressful without it. She was very professional, friendly and we had a positive outcome. Highly recommend.

    Posted 1 month ago

    Nalin W

    Mel Chin was my Legal Executive when I engaged the services of Redmans Solicitors to help with a redundancy matter. She was incredibly approachable and professional from start to finish. Specially I have to mention regarding prompt reply to all my email queries, It was super quick. I would thoroughly recommend Mel Chin. Many Thanks

    Posted 2 months ago

    Anonymous

    I'd highly recommend Redmans Solicitors. Mel was very helpful and assisted me throughout my case.

    Posted 2 months ago

    Anonymous

    Sacha was very thorough and very helpful, with great advice on when to act and when to wait on my case.

    Posted 2 months ago

    Anonymous

    I have been very pleased with the support I got from Redmans Solicitors on my case with my employer. Caroline has always helped me to put things in perspective and showed me different scenarios ultimately to help me taking the right decision. She was very professional and always available when I needed, and at the same time also emphatic which I found also really important to establish a strong relationship. Will definitely recommend!

    Posted 2 months ago

    Anonymous

    Prompt and efficient response to my enquiries. Excellent negotiating skills with my employer which considerably improved the terms of my settlement agreement.

    Posted 2 months ago

    Anonymous

    Very quick and professional service , Rana was very helpful

    Posted 2 months ago

    James G

    Very professional, knowledgeable and kept me informed at every stage of my case. I would highly recommend Redmans.

    Posted 3 months ago

    Pravina P

    Chris was really good and help solve my issues with current company. I would recommend him to anyone.

    Posted 3 months ago