Want to talk to an expert employment law solicitor?

You'll receive a callback from a specialist within an hour

In this article we’re going to take a look at the recent Employment Appeal Tribunal case of DSG Retail Ltd v Mackey [2013] UKEAT 0054_13_0807, a case which entailed an examination of whether an Employment Tribunal had erred in making a finding of unfair dismissal.

The facts in DSG Retail Ltd v Mackey

Mr Mackey, the Claimant, was employed by DSG Retail Ltd, the Respondent, for a period of 26 years between 1986 and 2012 and was at the time of his dismissal a store manager. Boxing Day was one of DSG Retail’s busiest days of the year and all staff were expected to work in the store on that day. The Claimant’s rugby team, the Scarlets, were playing on Boxing Day and it was noted by management at the Respondent that the Claimant could be seen leaving the store for a period of 2 hours that afternoon. The Claimant claimed that he was actually at the store at the time in question but the Respondent carried out a full investigation and summarily dismissed him.

The Employment Tribunal found that the dismissal was unfair, principally for the reason that the Respondent had stated that it had dismissed for a conduct reason but that the real reason was a breakdown of mutual trust and confidence between the parties.

The Respondent appealed the judgment.

The law relating to unfair dismissal

Under s.94 of the Employment Rights Act 1996 an employer must first identify a potentially fair reason for the dismissal of the employee and then be able to demonstrate that it made a decision that was within the range of reasonable responses in dismissing the employee (as well as taking steps to ensure procedural fairness in the dismissal).

The issues at hand in the appeal in this case were that the Employment Tribunal contended that the Respondent hadn’t identified the correct potentially fair reason for dismissal and that the Respondent had also failed to dismiss fairly in both the substantive and procedural senses.

The Employment Appeal Tribunal’s decision in DSG Retail Ltd v Mackey

The Employment Appeal Tribunal allowed the Respondent’s appeal. It found that the Employment Tribunal’s reason for its finding on the point relating to the potentially fair reason for dismissal was “unsupportable” and that Employment Tribunal had considered irrelevant points and/or overlooked important considerations and/or substituted its own view for that of the employer in a number of its findings.

Our view on the EAT’s judgment in DSG Retail Ltd v Mackey

The Employment Appeal Tribunal’s decision in DSG Retail Ltd v Mackey was undoubtedly the correct one, both legally and from a common-sense perspective. The point relating to identifying the potentially fair reason for dismissal can sometimes be a valid one in judging whether a Respondent has made a fair decision to dismiss (i.e. if it’s clearly confused competence with conduct) but this will rarely be a determining factor. Whether viewed as a “SOSR” potentially fair reason or a conduct issue the Employment Appeal Tribunal found that the Respondent was – after having undertaken what was acknowledged by the Tribunal to be a fair and thorough investigation – entitled to dismiss Mr Mackey for gross misconduct.

About

Redmans Employment Team deal with employment matters for both employers and employees, including drafting employment contracts and policies, advising employers and employees on compromise agreements, handling day-to-day HR issues, advising on restructures, and handling Employment Tribunal cases for both employers and employees Call 020 3397 3603 to speak to one of the members of our employment team or email us on enquiries@redmans.co.uk. Redmans have offices in Richmond, Chiswick, Hammersmith, Fulham, Kingston, Wimbledon, Ealing, Kings Cross and Marylebone (meetings strictly by appointment only).

Want to talk to an expert employment law solicitor?

You'll receive a callback from a specialist within an hour

Share →

Our awards

Request a callback

Your name

Your email

Your telephone number

Contact us

Please feel free to discuss your own position and concerns. Contact your nearest office on:

T: 020 3397 3603
E: enquiries@redmans.co.uk
W: www.redmans.co.uk

Testimonials

4.76 Average

164 Reviews

Samantha K

Absolutely brilliant thank you. Caroline Lewis is a legend

Posted 1 week ago

Anonymous

The legal advice was clear and helpful.

Posted 1 week ago

Davinder P

Good Service

Posted 2 weeks ago

Adrian V

I was using Redmans services for a Settlement Agreement. Very quick and professional service. The outcome was favourable and I was very pleased with the amendments and results. Pretty glad to recommend them for any type of legal advice.

Posted 2 weeks ago

Anonymous

Very responsive, efficient, clear and supportive. Thank you! Highly recommend.

Posted 2 weeks ago

Tiago S

Chris was always prompt to help me with legal matters that are beyond my comprehension and very helpful leasing with my former employer. I would recommend Redmans Solicitors to everyone who needs help.

Posted 2 weeks ago

Anonymous

Fast and professional advice tailored to what was needed. Thanks for your help Chris Hadrill and team.

Posted 2 weeks ago

Peter S

Really pleased with the outcome and the advice I had from Chris and Sacha.

Posted 3 weeks ago

Harika A

Redmans solicitor's helped me with my settlement agreement, Chris has been very helpful throughout the process.He was very prompt in his responses and made my settlement look simple.Special thanks to Caroline for her efficient communication, thorough explaination of contract terminology and negotiations.I highly reccommend Redmans solicitors for anyone seeking employment related legal help.

Posted 3 weeks ago

Anonymous

Good and quick service

Posted 3 weeks ago

Ricky D

Very satisfying to be assured of such attention and professionalism.

Posted 3 weeks ago

Anonymous

Excellent service - thankyou

Posted 3 weeks ago

Anonymous

Efficient, timely and friendly support and advice

Posted 3 weeks ago

Ahmed S

They are always on hand when you need them and provide support even when its not necessary.

Posted 3 weeks ago

Nemen S

Wonderful experience.Chris was very responsive and provided an excellent service. A real professional who I would recommend to anyone

Posted 3 weeks ago

Anonymous

Their guidance was clear and they provided me with all the information I required. Friendly yet professional

Posted 3 weeks ago

Anonymous

Chris @ Redmans assisted me with an employment issue. Firstly, he was very proactive in coming back to my initial enquiry and then helped to clearly lay out the options that I had in relation to my position. He then assisted with the preparation of my case, which led to a very satisfactory outcome. I would highly recommend the quality of service & professionalism offered by Redmans Solicitors.

Posted 3 weeks ago

Anonymous

Great service

Posted 3 weeks ago

Anonymous

Chris was very effective and decisive in dealing with my matter. I felt guided, and the pressure to make decisions was taken off my shoulders; he knew what needed to be done and I was happy to follow his advice. The result of the legal dispute was a great success for me. He is also kind and personable. The only thing that I would say it could be improved, is the accuracy of cost estimation at the beginning: not many activites, that could not have been forseen had to take place, but costs went up more than double in the end. Overall very good and trustworthy. I would definately recommend and use Redmans services again.

Posted 3 weeks ago

Liz P

An excellent professional service was provided by Chris Hadrill and Mel Chin. Efficient and trustworthy - would highly recommend this company.

Posted 1 month ago

Anonymous

Redmans Solicitors were great. They were able to advice me quickly and efficiently! I would recommend them, as a good solicitors to use.

Posted 1 month ago