Want to talk to an expert employment law solicitor?

You'll receive a callback from a specialist within an hour

The case of Barchester Healthcare Ltd v Tayeh concerns unfair dismissal – specifically whether it was reasonable for the Respondent to dismiss the Claimant

The facts in Barchester Healthcare Ltd v Tayeh

Mrs Tayeh (“the Claimant”) commenced employment with Magnolia Court Care Home (“the Care Home”) in 1996 as a registered nurse. Barchester Healthcare Ltd (“the Respondent”) subsequently took over the Care Home and the Claimant’s contract of employment was transferred to the Respondent. In December 2009 two managers of the Respondent visited the Care Home unannounced and found several shortcomings in how the Care Home was run. A number of these shortcomings concerned the area of the Care Home of which the Claimant was in charge. A series of investigatory meetings followed. However, on 10 February 2010 another incident occurred when a resident of the Care Home fell and suffered a fractured hip. The Respondent was unhappy that the Claimant hadn’t visited the resident for 3 hours when her shift began and that the Claimant hadn’t filled in the necessary paperwork. The Claimant was disciplined and dismissed  on 11 March 2010 after a disciplinary hearing on 4 March 2010. The Claimant subsequently submitted a claim for unfair dismissal.

The Employment Tribunal found in the Claimant’s favour in her unfair dismissal claim. The Respondent appealed on a number of grounds, one of which being that the Employment Tribunal had substituted its own view on fairness for that of the employer. The Claimant also cross-appealed on issues relating to remedy – she had been held to be at fault for her dismissal (50% contributory fault) and her compensation was further reduced by 12.5% for Polkey reasons.

The law relating to unfair dismissal (particularly substantive unfair dismissal)

An employee has the right not to be unfairly dismissed under s.94 of the Employment Rights Act 1996. There are two (crude) “branches” of unfair dismissal – substantive unfair dismissal and procedural unfair dismissal. A dismissal will be substantively unfair if it falls outside of the range of reasonable responses in the circumstances. A dismissal will be procedurally unfair if, for example, the Respondent fails to carry out a disciplinary procedure, fails to consider necessary evidence, or treats the Claimant inconsistently (among others).

In order for a dismissal to be substantively fair the following must have occurred:

  1. A reasonably thorough investigation must have been carried out into the allegations
  2. The Respondent must have a reasonable belief in the Claimant’s “guilt” based on these investigations
  3. The Respondent must have an honest belief in the Claimant’s “guilt”

Should these three elements be demonstrated the Respondent will have a strong chance of successfully defending the Employment Tribunal proceedings.

An important point relating to substantive unfair dismissal is that the Employment Tribunal must look at the employer’s subjective state of mind at the time of the decision to dismiss. The Employment Tribunal must not substitute its view on the objective fairness of the dismissal but must consider what the employer believed on the balance of probabilities.

The Employment Appeal Tribunal’s decision in Barchester Healthcare Ltd v Tayeh

The Employment Appeal Tribunal upheld the Respondent’s appeal and substituted in its place a finding of fair dismissal. The Employment Appeal Tribunal came to the conclusion that the Employment Tribunal had substituted its view on fairness instead of starting with the employer’s reasoning and applying the range of responses test.

Our specialist employment lawyers’ thoughts on Barchester Healthcare Ltd v Tayeh

This is an interesting case concerning unfair dismissal under employment law. The most important piece of information that can be gleaned from this judgment is that Employment Tribunals cannot consider the justice of the dismissal itself, it can only consider what the employer’s reasons for dismissing the employee were and whether the dismissal fell within the reasonable range of responses in the circumstances.

About Chris Hadrill

Chris is a specialist employment lawyer at Redmans. He specialises in contentious and non-contentious employment matters, including breach of contract claims, compromise agreements and Employment Tribunal cases. He writes on employment law matters on a variety of websites, including Direct 2 Lawyers, Lawontheweb.co.uk, LegalVoice, the Justice Gap and his own blog. Contact Chris by emailing him at chadrill@redmans.co.uk

Want to talk to an expert employment law solicitor?

You'll receive a callback from a specialist within an hour

Share →

Our awards

Request a callback

    Your first name (required)

    Your last name (required)

    Your email (required)

    Your telephone number (required)

    Brief details of your enquiry

    Testimonials

    4.79 Average

    274 Reviews

    Mary B

    I was very happy with the work Chris did for me. I believe with his help I secured a more favourable outcome both financially and in terms of clauses contained in the legal agreement I ultimately signed. I had utmost trust and confidence in the advice Chris provided throughout. Chris kept me informed at every stage and I found him very efficient at bringing matters to a conclusion without unnecessary delay.

    Posted 1 day ago

    Mark M

    I found Redmans very easy to work with. Mel was very responsive, her advice led to an improved settlement. . Recommended.!

    Posted 3 days ago

    Anonymous

    Fantastic service. I would recommend Redmans to anyone who needed a Solicitor. The communication was second to none and consistent clear guidance was given.

    Posted 5 days ago

    Anonymous

    Everyone I dealt with at Redmans were professional, empathetic & always responded promptly and helped make the transition as smooth & efficient as possible for me. If you need legal advice, don’t hesitate & contact the team.

    Posted 1 week ago

    Anonymous

    Sacha was incredibly helpful and professional. Timely and accurate advice at a time I most needed it. I was extremely impressed and grateful.

    Posted 1 week ago

    Sue W

    The people at Redmans talk to you with respect and make you feel like they take your situation personal. They clearly care and are extremely professional. I have recommended Redmans to many people.

    Posted 3 weeks ago

    Anonymous

    Redmans Solicitors were consistently prompt, efficient and professional from the start of my reaching out to them for support in relation to contentious negotiations of an employment matter that continued for almost two months resulting in a positive settlement agreement. Chris Hadrill was diligent, thorough, empathetic and objective in his advice and guidance, showing deep and broad knowledge of the law and legal processes plus extensive practical experience in handling complex matters, resulting in clear and pragmatic advice in ambiguous circumstances that resulted in a very good outcome. I fully recommend Chris Hadrill and Redmans Solicitors! I have made this review anonymous purely because of the confidentiality obligations in the settlement agreement concluded.

    Posted 1 month ago

    Michelle W

    Redmans solicitors provided legal support and advice for a settlement agreement. Excellent customer service, very professional. The senior associate solicitor kept me updated throughout the process, showed empathy and the agreement was signed-off / completed within the agreed timeline.

    Posted 1 month ago

    Mark W

    Redmans Solicitors were extremely professional and helpful! Chris Hadrill handled my case and was an amazing help! His guidance, advice and understanding to my redundancy settlement were always clear, concise and very helpful and I am very grateful to him, and glad I found Redmans to help with my settlement. I highly recommend them!

    Posted 1 month ago

    Alison M

    Very happy with the advice I received

    Posted 2 months ago

    Margaret A

    I found everything about the company to be extremely professional and efficient. During my initial contact with Chris, he listened well and was reassuring, so I felt confident that my case would be well handled. Caroline was excellent at explaining all the legal points and answering my questions, as well as being very supportive and understanding throughout the process. I would definitely recommend this company.

    Posted 2 months ago

    Sanja K

    Very efficient and professional service.

    Posted 2 months ago

    Anonymous

    I found the advice I was given by Redmans Solicitors to be clear and useful and found the solicitor on my case to be both knowledgeable and approachable.

    Posted 2 months ago

    Karen T

    Great service. Thank you.

    Posted 2 months ago

    Anonymous

    Excellent service from Chris & Mel Chin. The best outcome was achieved from the redundancy process. They were extremely thorough, listened carefully and acted swiftly on my behalf. I highly recommend Redmans Solicitors

    Posted 2 months ago

    Shanine M

    Excellent service, thank you so much!

    Posted 2 months ago

    Anonymous

    I found Caroline and Chris very Helpful and provided excellent service. Caroline especially provided great legal advice and made me feel at ease with the whole process. I would highly recommend them. Thank you!

    Posted 2 months ago

    Gayle B

    Excellent company very professional would definitely recommend

    Posted 2 months ago

    Alex K

    Redmans provided an excellent service, timely and effective. Will definitely recommend.

    Posted 2 months ago

    Anonymous

    Great job done on my employment law

    Posted 2 months ago

    Dominica S

    Caroline & Chris were very prompt and efficient.Very happy with the service and will definitely recommend Redmans Solicitor to everyone !

    Posted 2 months ago